Is it writing that makes us human?
18/02/2026

Memory is a faulty organ, one of my characters (in an as-yet unpublished) novel says to himself. He is scathing, upset that he can’t remember the details of his lover’s face, or her laugh. But if she was nearby, and he heard it, he would know it instantly, he is sure about that.
Is memory faulty, or flexible? I’ve been thinking about memory, and how it seems to change. If we experience something once, and try to explain it to someone, we could be accused of subjectivity. If someone else was there as well, it could be fact-checked. However, if days, months or years pass, the details may shift or fade.
Modern life, with our ubiquitous phones, may change this. I have strong memories of my children doing funny, unpredictable or charming things, because they were caught on video: that banana peel that my son ate, dropping the fruit over the high chair with a cheeky grin; that rendition of “Let it Go” sung by my daughter with a bucket over her head (Why? I might ask – for shyness, or better acoustics?) We will never have that three-year old again to ask, as she’s 13 now.
Is memory something that defines us? Most definitely, as individuals. All our accumulated memories from about the age of two or three onwards form our perception of reality, and the perception of self. Sci fi films and more popular works dig into this, and see what happens when memories fragment or are erased (that weird, kindof wonderful film from 2004, The Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, plays with this).
My earliest memory is of my mother teaching me to tie my shoe. I must have been about three at the time. There are no photographs of the event as far as I know, but I do feel it to be true. I vaguely remember starting to read around the same age – it was Dr Seuss’s classic, Hop on Pop, who could ever forget such a work of art. And I remember that I could never eat rice properly, and it would fall in a ring around the base of my chair.
Now with my own children, I wonder what their first memories are, but they can’t seem to tell me. Because they, too have seen the home videos and photographs. Even when they were the subject/object of attention, they may have memories of the event or not, but they are altered or sealed by the mobile phone in some caring person’s hand. But does it matter, if technology has enhanced the experience? Is something lost, or something gained?

What makes us human?
With all the swirls of discussion and worry around technology and artificial intelligence (AI), I have to wonder, is it memory that makes us human?
I’m not sure – scientists have long been testing the ability of mice and other animals to memorise mazes, for example, with the right incentive (Food = good; shock= bad). Also, salmon have their instinct to return to where they hatched as eggs; what is that instinct, if not memory?
What about other things? Can we say certain attributes make us human? A smile, falling in love, raising our children? Well, it seems like chimpanzees can smile, and I’ve known dog lovers who swear that there is a smile on their companion’s face going along with a rapid tail-wagging to signal happiness.
What about love? We’re not the only ones who couple up – swans mate for life, also penguins. And humans, it must be remembered, often don’t mate for all their lifetimes, although some of us aspire to.
Parental love and sacrifice? No, lots of example abound of animals going to great lengths to protect and raise their young. We see the images of penguins balancing the eggs on their feet in the freezing Antarctic ice, and backpackers in North America know never to get in between a mother brown bear and her cub.
Bipedalism? Nope – flamingos have that. But do they run marathons? Not yet, but migratory birds can fly thousands of miles, yet can’t walk very far. As far as running goes, cheetahs can sprint faster than any Olympian, greyhounds too, but their endurance might not be as good.
What about verbal expression? Discussion, language? Dolphins have complicated click-call signs with whistles and clicks that keep linguistic scientists entranced. Whale song carries across miles of ocean. Anyone in suburban London knows that foxes scream when they mate, so loud it makes you worry. Birdsong is obvious communication, possibly done not just for communication but for the sheer joy of it.
What else makes us human? What about forming communities? No, we have even special words for the collection of animals – a pride of lions, a murmuration of starlings, a murder of crows.
Worry? About the future? Perhaps. But a dog will put its tail between its legs and flatten its ears when they are left alone, presumably worrying that their owner won’t come back. Birds and other animals sense an earthquake before it strikes, and freeze silent as the grave. Is that worry, or just preparedness? It’s eerie, all the same.
What about writing?
Making significant marks on paper, papyrus or stone, does seem to be a particularly human attribute. Although animal behaviour specialists may write in to correct me, I don’t think footprints and scat tracking, although communication, can be in the same category as writing. You probably could find an example of people teaching chimpanzees to write or count, perhaps numbers and such. But I think writing sentences, such as poetry, prose, fiction or even just the humble shopping list may set us apart.
What about sign language? I think this has successfully been tried with our cousins, the great apes. Isn’t that speech, though? Or something in between speech and writing, as it signifies language, signifying meaning? But what are words, in any case, if not signifiers of meaning? One troubled soul trying to tell another what really happened on that fateful day. One grateful person communicating their great luck to another who will celebrate their good fortune.
I should do more research, read more. But in the meantime, I feel compelled to write, and learn.
So, in conclusion, to write may make us human, but a good deal of humility should be maintained at the same time. We are hardly the only important or expressive species in the great animal kingdom; we are a small, but significant breed. Still, there may be things that are uniquely human, and that brings us to the unanswerable question of… why?
But that is delving into philosophy, and we’ll have to explore that another day.
Comments? Refutations? Recommended reading? Please feel free to share your reflections below.

